Table of Contents
Have you ever stood in your kitchen, staring blankly at your fridge, wondering if you should grab that steak and nothing else, or if you could throw in some avocado and a modest portion of berries? If so, you’re likely contemplating the choice between two of the most talked-about dietary approaches today: the carnivore diet vs keto diet.
I remember my first encounter with these diets. After years of struggling with weight fluctuations and persistent inflammation, I found myself deep in research, toggling between tabs and comparing these two carb-restricting lifestyles. The promise of weight loss, mental clarity, and reduced inflammation was enticing, but deciding between them felt like choosing between two paths in a forest, both promising but distinctly different.
In today’s health-conscious world, low-carb diets have gained immense popularity, and with good reason. They’ve shown remarkable results for weight management, metabolic health, and even certain medical conditions. But when it comes to the carnivore diet vs keto, the differences are significant, despite their shared low-carb philosophy.
This comprehensive guide will walk you through everything you need to know about these two dietary approaches. We’ll explore their fundamental principles, health benefits, potential risks, and practical considerations to help you determine which might be the right fit for your unique body and lifestyle goals.
Whether you’re considering these diets for weight loss, health improvements, or specific medical concerns, understanding the nuances between carnivore and keto could be the key to your dietary success. So, let’s dive in and unravel the mysteries of these two popular low-carb lifestyles.
The carnivore diet is exactly what it sounds like—a diet consisting entirely of animal products. It’s perhaps the ultimate elimination diet, removing all plant foods from your plate.
When I first heard about people eating only meat, I was skeptical. But the carnivore diet has deep roots, inspired by traditional diets of certain indigenous peoples who thrived primarily on animal foods. Modern proponents believe that returning to this ancestral way of eating can eliminate many of the health problems associated with contemporary diets.
What You Can Eat on the Carnivore Diet:
What You Cannot Eat on the Carnivore Diet:
The carnivore diet is a zero-carb approach, making it the most restrictive form of low-carb eating. It’s an extreme version of elimination dieting, with proponents arguing that many plant foods contain antinutrients and compounds that can trigger inflammation and digestive issues in some people.
The ketogenic or “keto” diet takes a different approach. While still low in carbohydrates, it allows for a broader range of foods and focuses on achieving a metabolic state called ketosis.
I was first drawn to keto after reading about its benefits for epilepsy patients—its original medical purpose. The diet has since evolved into a popular approach for weight loss and metabolic health.
What You Can Eat on the Keto Diet:
What You Cannot Eat on the Keto Diet:
The keto diet typically limits carbohydrates to 20-50 grams per day, which is about 5-10% of total caloric intake. The remaining calories come from fat (70-80%) and protein (10-20%).
| Feature | Carnivore Diet | Keto Diet |
|---|---|---|
| Food Sources | Animal products only | Animal and select plant foods |
| Carbohydrate Content | Virtually zero | 20-50g per day (5-10% of calories) |
| Fat Intake | Varies, typically high | Very high (70-80% of calories) |
| Protein Intake | High | Moderate (10-20% of calories) |
| Vegetable Consumption | None | Limited low-carb options |
| Fruit Consumption | None | Very limited (mainly berries) |
| Dairy Inclusion | Limited, varies by individual | Yes, high-fat options |
| Primary Goal | Elimination of plant antinutrients | Achieving ketosis |
| Difficulty Level | Very challenging | Challenging |
While both diets share a low-carb approach, their philosophies, allowed foods and metabolic effects differ significantly.
The carnivore diet is rooted in the belief that humans evolved primarily as meat-eaters and that many modern health issues stem from the inclusion of plant foods in our diet. It’s an elimination diet at its core, removing all potential plant-based irritants.
In contrast, the keto diet is designed around a specific metabolic state—ketosis—where your body burns fat for fuel instead of carbohydrates. It’s more focused on macronutrient ratios than on eliminating specific food groups entirely.
How do the macronutrient ratios differ between the Carnivore and Keto diets?
The carnivore diet doesn’t prescribe specific macronutrient ratios. Since you’re eating only animal products, your intake will naturally be very high in protein and fat with minimal carbohydrates. Some carnivore dieters consume equal amounts of fat and protein, while others focus more heavily on fatty cuts of meat.
The keto diet, however, has clearly defined macronutrient targets:
This distinction is important because excessive protein consumption can potentially interfere with ketosis through a process called gluconeogenesis, where protein is converted to glucose.
Does the Carnivore diet induce ketosis?
Since the carnivore diet is virtually zero-carb, many assume it automatically induces ketosis. The reality is more nuanced.
The carnivore diet may or may not lead to ketosis, depending on several factors:
If a carnivore dieter consumes relatively high amounts of protein compared to fat, they might not enter deep ketosis due to gluconeogenesis. However, many carnivore dieters do experience some degree of ketosis, especially when consuming fattier cuts of meat.
The keto diet, on the other hand, is specifically designed to induce and maintain ketosis through careful macronutrient balance.
What foods are allowed on the Keto diet but not on the Carnivore diet?
The keto diet permits a wider variety of foods, including:
These foods provide various nutrients, antioxidants, and fiber that are absent in the carnivore diet.
How do the weight loss results typically compare between the carnivore diet and keto diet?
Both diets can be effective for weight loss, but they work through slightly different mechanisms.
The keto diet promotes weight loss through several pathways:
I’ve seen many keto dieters experience significant weight loss, particularly in the first few months. The diet’s ability to suppress appetite and stabilize blood sugar makes it easier to maintain a caloric deficit without feeling constantly hungry.
The carnivore diet may promote weight loss through:
Many people report more dramatic initial weight loss on the carnivore diet, possibly due to its more extreme nature and higher protein content. However, this rapid loss may partially consist of water weight and glycogen depletion.
For long-term, sustainable weight loss, the research currently favors the keto diet. It offers:
That said, individual results can vary significantly. Some people respond exceptionally well to the carnivore diet’s elimination approach, particularly those with food sensitivities or inflammatory conditions.
Both diets offer potential health benefits beyond weight loss, though the scientific evidence varies in strength.
What are the main goals of the Carnivore diet?
The carnivore diet is often pursued for:
Does the Carnivore diet help with inflammation?
Many anecdotal reports suggest the carnivore diet can dramatically reduce inflammation. Potential mechanisms include:
I’ve spoken with several people who experienced remarkable improvements in inflammatory conditions like arthritis, psoriasis, and inflammatory bowel disease after adopting the carnivore diet. However, scientific studies specifically on the carnivore diet’s anti-inflammatory effects are currently limited.
What are the main benefits of the keto diet compared to the carnivore diet?
The keto diet offers several advantages:
How does the Keto diet benefit blood sugar control?
The keto diet’s effects on blood sugar are well-documented:
Many studies show that the ketogenic diet can help manage or even reverse type 2 diabetes in some individuals. A 2018 study published in Diabetes Therapy found that 60% of participants were able to reverse their diabetes after one year on a ketogenic diet.
What are the mental health benefits of the Keto diet?
The keto diet may benefit mental health through several mechanisms:
Research suggests potential benefits for conditions like depression, anxiety, ADHD, and bipolar disorder, though more studies are needed.
No diet is without potential drawbacks, and both the carnivore and keto diets come with considerations you should be aware of.
Is the Carnivore diet safe long-term?
The long-term safety of the carnivore diet remains uncertain due to limited research. Concerns include:
How does the Carnivore diet affect cholesterol levels?
The impact on cholesterol is highly individual. Some carnivore dieters experience:
The traditional view that increased LDL automatically increases heart disease risk is being challenged, with some researchers suggesting that the context of the increase matters. However, if you have existing heart disease or familial hypercholesterolemia, medical supervision is essential.
What are the health risks of the Carnivore diet?
Potential risks include:
The keto diet also comes with potential concerns:
How do the digestive effects of the carnivore diet compare to those of the keto diet?
Digestive experiences differ significantly:
The carnivore diet often leads to:
The keto diet’s digestive effects include:
Is the Keto diet more sustainable than the Carnivore diet?
For most people, the keto diet offers greater long-term sustainability due to:
That said, some individuals find the carnivore diet’s simplicity and elimination approach more sustainable for their specific health needs and preferences.
Can you exercise on the Carnivore diet?
Yes, you can exercise on both diets, but there are considerations:
Carnivore diet and exercise:
Keto diet and exercise:
Both diets can be more expensive than standard diets, but in different ways:
The carnivore diet:
The keto diet:
What are the most common misconceptions about the carnivore diet versus keto?
Many misconceptions surround both diets:
Common carnivore diet misconceptions:
Common keto diet misconceptions:
How do you transition from Keto to Carnivore?
If you’re considering switching from keto to carnivore, a gradual approach works best:
The transition typically takes 2-4 weeks, with most adaptation symptoms resolving within a month.
If you’re new to low-carb diets, the keto diet may be an easier starting point:
However, if you suspect plant-based food sensitivities or have severe autoimmune issues, starting with carnivore as an elimination diet might be worthwhile under medical supervision.
What are the best protein sources for the Carnivore diet?
Top protein sources include:
Can you eat dairy on the Carnivore diet?
Dairy is a gray area in the carnivore diet:
Can you drink coffee on the Carnivore diet?
Coffee is technically a plant product and thus not strictly carnivore. However:
What are the best snacks for the Carnivore diet?
Carnivore-friendly snacks include:
Popular keto-friendly meals include:
Are there any specific medical conditions that the carnivore diet is better suited for than keto?
Some conditions that might respond better to carnivores include:
The keto diet may be preferable for:
Always consult healthcare providers: Both diets can significantly impact health and may interact with medications or existing conditions.
Whether you choose carnivore or keto, certain products can support your journey:
Choosing between the carnivore diet and keto ultimately comes down to your individual health needs, goals, and lifestyle preferences.
The carnivore diet might be right for you if:
The keto diet might be better if:
Remember that neither diet has to be permanent. Many people cycle between different approaches or modify them to suit their changing needs. Some even create a hybrid approach, following a mostly carnivore diet with occasional low-carb plant foods.
The most important factor in your success will be finding an approach you can stick with consistently. Listen to your body, track your results, and be willing to adjust your approach based on how you feel and the outcomes you experience.
Have you tried either of these diets? What was your experience? I’d love to hear about your journey in the comments below. And if you found this comparison helpful, please share it with others who might be weighing their low-carb options.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and should not be considered medical advice. Always consult with a healthcare provider before making significant dietary changes, especially if you have existing health conditions or take medications.
"Discover everything about keto yogurt in our comprehensive guide. Learn which brands are lowest in carbs, how to make your own, and delicious ways to enjoy yogurt while staying in ketosis. Find the perfect yogurt for your ketogenic lifestyle
Discover the best keto desserts recipes for beginners! Learn how to make mouthwatering low-carb treats with our step-by-step guide to keto-friendly sweets.
Discover 10 delicious keto-friendly avocado recipes plus the science behind why avocados are perfect for your low-carb diet. Learn how to maximize health benefits and keep carbs low!
Discover everything about keto fat bombs - what they are, how they support ketosis, and why they're essential for your low-carb lifestyle. Learn top recipes, ingredient options, and expert tips for making delicious sweet and savory fat bombs at home. Perfect for beginners and keto veterans looking to satisfy cravings while maintaining ketosis.
Are tomatoes keto-friendly? Discover the exact carb counts of different tomato varieties, learn which tomato products to enjoy and avoid, and explore delicious low-carb tomato recipes in this comprehensive guide to incorporating tomatoes into your ketogenic lifestyle without compromising ketosis
Discover how ACV gummies can support weight loss, keto diets, and overall health without the harsh taste of liquid apple cider vinegar. Our complete guide covers benefits, dosage, and top product recommendations for 2025.
